World Hum | Travel | The Man Who Cast Starbucks from the Forbidden City

Travel dispatches from a shrinking planet

World Hum’s Most Read: June 28-July 3

What We Loved This Week: Def Leppard in Greece, Austrian Competence and Freedom in Colombia

The LAX Theme Building, Then and Now

As a Woman, Can I Really Travel Without Much Fear for my Safety?

Vagabonding traveler Rolf Potts answers your questions about travel

Inside Slum Tourism

With mixed feelings, Rob Verger recently signed on for a tour of Rio de Janeiro’s favelas. He looks back on the experience—and the photos he was allowed to take.

Break Bread and Brie in France

Great cheese abounds in the land of Gaul, but dig in and you risk committing any number of faux pas. Terry Ward explains how to partake of the nation’s famed fromage with savoir faire.

10 Wanderlust-Inducing Summer Concerts

Call it world music or global pop or the sound of the world hum. Ben Keene reveals 10 acts on tour that are sure to transport you. Plus videos.

Bryan Mealer: ‘War and Deliverance in Congo’

The former AP correspondent traveled up the Congo River. Frank Bures asks the author of “All Things Must Fight to Live” about following in the wake of Joseph Conrad.

A Journey Into ‘The Second World’

Some bureaucrats joke that they would never claim expertise about countries they had not at least flown over. In an excerpt from his new book, Parag Khanna argues that real global understanding can only come from serious travel.

BOOKS

�The Worst Guidebook Writer Ever�?

Lonely Planet author Robert Reid reviews Thomas Kohnstamm’s “Do Travel Writers Go to Hell?” and weighs in on the controversy surrounding it

TRAVEL BLOG

7.19.07

The Man Who Cast Starbucks from the Forbidden City

Why did Starbucks close its outlet in Beijing’s Forbidden City? In part, because of the campaign launched by a popular Chinese TV news anchor on his blog. His name is Rui Chenggang. He travels the globe and speaks near perfect English, according a terrific profile in the Los Angeles Times. Seven months ago, Rui wrote that the Starbucks outlet “undermined the Forbidden City’s solemnity and trampled over Chinese culture.” His post prompted a widespread response. Interestingly, he said he still drinks Starbucks coffee—there are well over 200 outlets in China—he just doesn’t think the chain should be hawking lattes in such a sacred Chinese site.

Rui worries that modernization will lead to homogenization in China. He said many people are now asking how the Chinese will preserve their country’s identity.

Writes Mitchell Landsberg:

His answer, of course, is the Forbidden City—that, as much as anything, defines China’s cultural heritage.

“I was having lunch with an Indian person today, and I said, ‘Would you Indians allow a Starbucks to be inside the Taj Mahal?’ And he said, ‘No, of course not, we would never let that happen.’ “

“The Forbidden City,” Rui added, “is not an airport.”

Photo by [Satbir] via Flickr, (Creative Commons).

Posted by Jim Benning • 7.19.07
Categories: Weblog • China

Permalink • Comments (3)

COMMENTS

Although China’s identity issues have far more to do with internal politics than external influences, I can understand the sentiment of not wanting starbucks in the forbidden city. However, if they allow other peddlers in the site, it’s only fair to re-examine them as well.

By Adam Bray in Mui Ne, Vietnam on 8.13.07 at 08:39 PM

I recently came back from China, with a stay in Beijing and a tour of the Forbidden City. Starbucks inside the Forbidden City would be awful and bordering on sacrilege. The Forbidden City is a beautiful place and awe inspiring. Starbucks would be tawdy commerialization of a wonderous historical site. Peddlers are not allowed within the Forbidden City, although you will certainly find the peddlers everywhere outside the walls with some interesting items for sell and law-enforcement officers beating them, literally, off you on every corner. I got a wonderful kite right across the street in the Square before entering the gates.

By on 1.3.08 at 11:05 AM

I don’t think Starbucks has a big enough influence to change the Chinese Culture there are a lot other things that might be able to change the culture but not Starbucks.

By on 1.16.08 at 10:09 AM